• Does the moon exist only when someone is looking at it?

    Education

    Full_moon_small_432_

    Recently, one of Einstein's young friends, Abraham Pais, reported that round about 1950 Einstein had asked him if he really believed that the moon existed only if he looked at it.

    Einstein himself had no doubts as to the answer. In his view the commonsense belief is correct. The moon does exist in objective reality whether or not anyone is observing it.

    So why did he ask the question?

    He did so because he had long disagreed with a lot of the most important and influential physicists of his time, about the interpretation of that area of physics known as quantum physics that deals with the behaviour of objects in the microphysical, subatomic, world. Many of these physicists were committed to an interpretation from which it follows that nothing - the moon included - exists unless it is being observed. Einstein wanted to know whether Pais was on his side or theirs. what about you? are you a realist or not?

  • I wondered the same just a few days ago actually. I wondered if the mirror actually reflects anything when I'm not about. Guess if you leave a concave mirror at the right angle towards the sun it might burn a hole in the wall. But that doesnt really answer the question. Is the moon an optical illusion then? Hindus believed it was part of heaven so impossible that people could land there.

Leave a Response

Fields marked * are required


No file selected (must be a .jpg, .png or .gif image file)


Once published, you will have 15 minutes to edit this response.

Cancel

Just one Allumonde Ring...


Can buy three months of education and expenses for one war-orphaned child in Sierra Leone.
Click here to support the Global Action Foundation with an Allumonde Ring.