Start your own group! All DESIGN 21 members have the ability to create organizations.

Create A Group
Human Rights Poster Project

Human Rights Poster Project

Communication, Arts & Culture, Education

82 Supporters

  • Critique

    Education


    In response to Rights = Humanity, posted by Benny Chu,
    in the thread Rights = Humanity

    Does this design reflect a(n)...

    • well developed and easily understood concept?

    This intended conceptual approach might be appropriate for the subject at hand but the selection of symbols to communicate critical messages are mostly meaningless and irrelevant to the audience it intends to address. In Africa we have a saying that the ‘porridge fell on the floor between the pot and the table’ which is exactly what I believe happened here. Your intentions were good but you did not consider or researched the power of visual symbols effectively to convey your messages effectively and inclusively. For instance, the basketball symbol would not be recognised by a broad audience outside of the USA, Canada, Cuba, China and Australia because it is not an popular international sport and therefore the symbol would be meaningless. The use of the ‘W’ to signify water is not relevant because in most countries it would mean ‘women’s toilets’. ‘$’ would mean cash rather than property, your symbol for discrimination is totally unclear in any culture and the same pertains to ‘no acid attract’ (what does this actually mean?). ‘F’ representing food actually means female toilets in many countries, and your proposed image for ‘no torture’ would mean ‘smoking zone’ in many countries.

    • level of social engagement?

    Unsuccessful.

    • understanding of the issues reflected in the poster?

    Unsuccessful

    • sense of internationalism and accessibility?

    Unsuccessful

Leave a Response

Fields marked * are required


No file selected (must be a .jpg, .png or .gif image file)


Once published, you will have 15 minutes to edit this response.

Cancel

Human Rights Poster Project at Designmatters at Art Center explores the social and humanitarian benefits of design and responsible business.

Join This Group

Human Rights Poster Project

1700 Lida Street
Pasadena, CA 91103
United States

Contact Human Rights Poster Project
http://www.artcenter.edu/designmatters/

Moderator: elisa ruffino